AI Search Visibility

AthenaHQ vs Peec AI vs Noma: Which Tracks What

AthenaHQ vs Peec compared on engines, prompt setup and tasks, using only the vendors' own pages, with the case for Noma's 13 AI engines.

Sheetal Shakshi15 Nov 202613 min read
AthenaHQ vs Peec AI vs Noma: Which Tracks What

On their own pages, AthenaHQ Starter ($295/month) lists 11 models and Peec AI's brand plans ($95 to $495/month) include 3 active models chosen from a list of 8, with up to 26 on custom Enterprise. Noma tracks 13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude, polled daily. The right pick depends on how many engines you need, how prompts are counted and how results turn into tasks.

AthenaHQ vs Peec AI is mostly a question of engines, prompts and tasks: AthenaHQ's Starter plan lists 11 models at $295 a month, while Peec AI's brand plans let you pick 3 models from a list of 8 for $95 to $495 a month. Noma by Nurdd tracks 13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude. Below, every rival fact comes from the rival's own public page.

Key takeaways

  • Count engines per plan, not per vendor. Peec AI's Starter, Pro and Advanced plans each include 3 active models; AthenaHQ's Starter lists 11; Noma tracks 13 AI engines.
  • Check how usage is metered. Peec AI meters prompts, models and frequency; AthenaHQ meters credits, where its plans page says 1 credit equals 1 AI response.
  • Ask how a tracked prompt becomes a task. Both rivals publish an actions workflow, so test it on one real content gap rather than trusting the feature name.
  • Verify prices on the vendor's own page. One third-party page we read lists an older Peec AI entry price than Peec AI's pricing page does.
  • Run the same 10 to 15 buyer prompts in each tool for a few days before you commit to a year.

How did we compare AthenaHQ, Peec AI and Noma?

We read the pricing, product and plan pages of AthenaHQ and Peec AI in November 2026, plus AthenaHQ's own comparison page against Peec AI, which is a competitor's view and is treated that way here. We also read two third-party comparisons, Menra's and DeepSmith's, to see how they frame the choice.

This post uses a three-part test: Coverage, Setup, Action, or CSA.

  • Coverage: which AI engines are tracked on the plan you would actually buy.
  • Setup: how prompts are created, grouped, localised and counted against your allowance.
  • Action: how a tracked result becomes a task someone can finish.

On top of the CSA test, we add a usage-metering calculation, an engine list lined up by plan and a three-day trial checklist you can run yourself.

AthenaHQ vs Peec AI at a glance: what does each tool track?

Both tools measure whether your brand is named and cited in AI answers. They differ in how many engines sit inside the plan and how the allowance is counted. The table uses each vendor's own plan pages, checked in November 2026.

FeatureAthenaHQPeec AINoma
Engines on the entry paid plan11 models listed on Starter3 active models, chosen from 8 listed13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude
Engines named by the vendorChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI, MistralChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overview, AI Mode, Gemini, Naver AI Briefing, ERNIE (Baidu), Bing AI ModeChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude, among 13
ClaudeYes, on StarterNot in the 8-model list for Starter to Advanced; Claude models appear in the Enterprise listYes
Tracking frequencyCredit-basedDaily on Starter, Pro and AdvancedPolled daily
Allowance unitCredits (3,600 on Starter)Prompts (50, 150, 350)Not compared here

Sources: AthenaHQ plans page, November 2026 and Peec AI pricing page, November 2026. Noma details come from Nurdd's own product facts.

Which AI visibility tool tracks the most engines?

Noma tracks 13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude. AthenaHQ's Starter plan lists 11 models. Peec AI's Starter, Pro and Advanced plans each include 3 active models.

Noma by Nurdd tracks 13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude, polled daily, and records whether a brand is named and which page each citation comes from.

Peec AI's own pricing page lists up to 26 LLM models on its custom, annual Enterprise plan, so that ceiling is higher than 13. The difference is access: that range sits behind a sales conversation, while Peec AI's Starter, Pro and Advanced plans have 3 active models. AthenaHQ's own comparison page says Peec AI's Enterprise lists up to 12, while Peec AI's page lists up to 26, which is why you should read each vendor's page yourself.

What the engine counts do not tell you

A bigger engine list is not automatically better coverage. Engines overlap: Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode both draw on Google Search, and Bing AI Mode sits on Microsoft's stack. What matters is whether the engines your buyers use are in your plan, and whether you can see them side by side.

Peec AI's AI Visibility page advises choosing the models that send the most traffic. That presumes you already know your traffic mix. Most teams do not, and a tool that tracks 13 engines lets the data show you where the mentions are. Our guide to Peec AI vs Noma and which tracks more AI engines goes deeper on this one row.

How does Peec AI set up prompts?

Peec AI sets up prompts as a tracked list with a fixed allowance per plan: 50 on Starter, 150 on Pro and 350 on Advanced, each run daily on your chosen models. Its pricing page lists prompt suggestions, prompts from keywords, personas, bulk import, regions and languages, and topics, tags and categories.

Peec AI states that countries are limited to 1 on Starter and 3 on Pro and Advanced, while languages, competitors and users are unlimited. It also says monthly AI answers are tracked prompts multiplied by active models and frequency: 4,500 on Starter, 13,500 on Pro and 31,500 on Advanced.

How does AthenaHQ set up prompts?

AthenaHQ sets up prompts without a prompt cap and meters usage in credits instead. Its plans page lists unlimited topics and prompts and unlimited competitors on Starter, with country-level support. The Enterprise tier adds multi-region and multi-language support and persona targeting.

The catch is the credit meter. AthenaHQ's plans page says 1 credit equals 1 AI response, and Starter includes 3,600 credits. Every prompt you run on every model draws from that pool, so unlimited prompts are bounded by credits in practice. API access and extra credits are listed as paid add-ons on top of the $295 Starter price.

Worked example: how each vendor's meter works out

The numbers below are our own arithmetic on figures from the two vendors' pages. They assume a 30-day month and AthenaHQ's statement that 1 credit is 1 AI response. They show how each vendor meters usage, not which plan is the better value, because the plans cover different numbers of engines.

PlanPublished pricePublished or derived answers per monthPrice per answer (our calculation)
Peec AI Starter$95/month4,500 (50 prompts, 3 models, daily)about $0.021
Peec AI Pro$245/month13,500about $0.018
Peec AI Advanced$495/month31,500about $0.016
AthenaHQ Starter$295/month3,600 creditsabout $0.082

The meters differ in kind. Tracking 50 prompts daily across 11 models would take 16,500 answers a month (50 x 11 x 30), about 4.6 times AthenaHQ Starter's 3,600 credits. Inside Starter's credits you could run about 10 prompts daily across 11 models (3,600 divided by 330). Peec AI's Starter equivalent is 50 prompts on 3 models. Prompt count and engine count trade off against each other in both vendors' plans, so ask what you give up to get breadth.

Noma has a 3-day free trial, with a card taken at signup and billing from day 3, so you can run the same arithmetic on your own prompts at nomahq.app. For more on how metering differs between vendors, see Peec AI pricing vs Noma and software for AI search visibility pricing.

How many prompts do you actually need?

Most brands need fewer prompts than they fear and more engines than they expect. A starting set of 10 to 15 buyer questions is enough to compare tools, and the right long-term number depends on how many categories, countries and personas you serve. Our guide to how many prompts you need and the post on which prompts to track cover the sizing in detail.

The same prompt asked on 13 engines gives you 13 data points, one per engine. A plan with 3 active models gives you 3. If your question is where you appear, engine breadth increases the information you get per prompt.

How do results become tasks in AthenaHQ and Peec AI?

Both vendors publish an actions layer. Peec AI's Actions page describes prioritised opportunities with impact estimates, technical blockers that make content harder for AI engines to read, content edits in a built-in editor, content briefs, earned-source suggestions and corrections for inaccurate claims about your brand.

AthenaHQ's plans page lists on-page and off-page actions and a content optimization agent on Starter. Its Enterprise tier adds the Athena Citation Engine (ACE), a Knowledge Base with claim review and an Oracle feature for discrepancy detection. AthenaHQ's comparison page describes ACE as an agent that analyses content gaps and drafts optimisations.

Both approaches generate tasks, so a feature checkbox will not separate them. What separates them is whether a task is specific enough to finish. A good task names the page, the claim to change and the prompt it came from. A poor one says to improve your content.

How Noma turns results into tasks

Noma shows citation frequency by category, competitor comparison and recommendations to improve AI visibility. It also records which page each citation comes from. The post on turning tracking data into tasks shows the routine: pick the prompts where a competitor is named and you are not, then open the cited pages and decide what each one has that yours lacks.

Which should you choose? A decision table

Use this table to match your situation to the row that matters most. It is built from the three CSA questions and the published plan facts above.

If your priority is...Check this on AthenaHQCheck this on Peec AIWhy Noma fits
Seeing every major engine, including Claude11 models on Starter, credit-metered3 active models on Starter, Pro and Advanced13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude
Source-level citation detailSources and competitor insights listedSource analytics listedRecords the page behind each citation
Knowing the meterAdd-ons for API and extra creditsFixed prompt tiers; Enterprise custom3-day free trial to test on your own prompts
Tasks from resultsOn-page and off-page actionsActions page with briefs and correctionsRecommendations to improve AI visibility

Sources: AthenaHQ plans page and Peec AI pricing and Actions pages, November 2026; Noma facts from Nurdd.

Why does Noma belong in an AthenaHQ vs Peec AI comparison?

Noma by Nurdd belongs in this comparison because it is built around breadth of engines. It tracks 13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude, polled daily, and shows whether your brand is named, which competitors appear and which page each citation comes from. It suits teams whose main question is where they are missing, not how deep one engine goes.

Want to see Noma for your own brand? Book a demo to see Noma.

Where Noma wins or ties on the rows above

  • Engine count: Noma tracks 13 AI engines, against Peec AI's 3 active models on Starter, Pro and Advanced and AthenaHQ Starter's 11 listed models. Peec AI Enterprise lists up to 26 on a custom plan.
  • Claude coverage: Noma ties AthenaHQ Starter and covers a model that Peec AI's 8-model list for Starter to Advanced does not name.
  • Daily polling: Noma ties Peec AI's daily frequency on Starter, Pro and Advanced.
  • Trial: Noma has a 3-day free trial. A card is taken at signup, billing starts on day 3 and nothing is charged if you cancel before then.

If you want more than a comparison, see the head-to-head pages for Noma vs AthenaHQ and Noma vs Peec AI, and the broader best AI search visibility tools comparison.

What should you check before trusting any tool's numbers?

Check that the vendor's numbers agree with its own pricing page. Third-party pages go stale: Menra's comparison quotes a Peec AI first paid tier of $89 a month, while Peec AI's own pricing page in November 2026 shows $95. AthenaHQ's comparison page says Peec AI's Enterprise lists up to 12 models, while Peec AI's page lists up to 26.

The pattern is not malice, just age. Prices and model lists change quickly, so treat any comparison, including this one, as a snapshot with a date. Our guide on how to verify AI search tool data covers the bigger issue: AI answers vary between runs, so ask any vendor how it samples and averages.

How to run a 3-day tool test: a checklist

Run the same test in every tool so the results are comparable. Noma's 3-day trial is built for it, and our trial test plan expands each step.

  1. Write 12 buyer prompts. Use four category questions, four comparison questions and four problem questions, phrased the way a customer would type them.
  2. Fix the variables. Same country, same language, same competitor list in every tool.
  3. List the engines you get. Write down which engines each tool runs on your plan, and whether Claude, Copilot and Google's AI features are included.
  4. Count the answers used. Note how many prompts, credits or answers each run consumed, then scale to a month.
  5. Compare mention results. For three prompts, check that the tool's result matches what you see when you ask the engine yourself.
  6. Open the cited sources. Pick one prompt where a competitor wins and find the page behind the citation.
  7. Turn one result into one task. Does the tool give you a page, a claim and a change you can ship this week?
  8. Check the export. Confirm you can pull the data out in a format your team can report from.

Our GEO readiness scorecard is a free 12-factor check you can run before you start, so you know which gaps are on your site and which are in the tracking.

What mistakes do buyers make when comparing these tools?

  • Comparing vendors, not plans. Peec AI's Enterprise lists up to 26 models, while its Starter includes 3. AthenaHQ's tiers differ too, so read the plan you would buy.
  • Ignoring the meter. Credits, prompts and answers are different units. Convert each to answers per month before comparing price.
  • Buying on engine count alone. Engines should match where your buyers search. Check the engines that matter for your category, such as Claude or Microsoft Copilot.
  • Treating a score as a task. A visibility percentage tells you where you stand. It does not tell you what to publish.
  • Trusting old prices. Take pricing from the vendor's page on the day you decide.

What happens after you pick a tool?

The tool is the measurement; the work is on your site and in the sources AI engines cite. After the trial, set a weekly review of share of voice, citations and competitor mentions. The posts on AI search share of voice and AI search monitoring alerts show what to watch and how often.

If you want help with the content and source work, Nurdd's team runs it through its generative engine optimization services, measured in Noma. If you are weighing other options, the AthenaHQ alternatives guide and Peec AI alternatives compared list what to check.

How we researched this

We reviewed the public pricing, plan and product pages of AthenaHQ and Peec AI, AthenaHQ's published comparison against Peec AI, and two third-party comparison pages. All pages were checked in November 2026, the publication month of this post. Price-per-answer figures and the 16,500-answer example are our own arithmetic on published numbers. We did not run hands-on tests of AthenaHQ or Peec AI, and we did not interview customers. Noma facts come from Nurdd's own product information.

Conclusion

AthenaHQ and Peec AI differ on how they count engines, prompts and usage: AthenaHQ Starter lists 11 models and meters credits, while Peec AI's standard plans include 3 active models and meter prompts. Noma tracks 13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude, daily.

The quickest way to settle it is to test your own prompts. Book a demo to see Noma. You can also read how Nurdd works first.

Frequently asked questions

AthenaHQ vs Peec AI: which is better?

It depends on the metric you care about. AthenaHQ lists 11 models on Starter and meters credits, while Peec AI includes 3 active models on its standard plans and meters prompts. Noma tracks 13 AI engines, so it fits teams that want broad coverage.

Which AI visibility tool tracks the most engines?

Noma tracks 13 AI engines, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude. AthenaHQ Starter lists 11 models. Peec AI's Starter, Pro and Advanced plans include 3 active models, and its custom Enterprise plan lists up to 26.

How much does Peec AI cost?

Peec AI's pricing page lists Starter at $95 a month, Pro at $245 and Advanced at $495, with Enterprise custom and annual. Prices are in USD and were checked in November 2026. Check the page before you buy, as plans change.

How much does AthenaHQ cost?

AthenaHQ's plans page lists a free Essential tier with $25 of credit, Starter at $295 a month with 3,600 credits, and custom Enterprise. API access and extra credits are paid add-ons. The figures were checked in November 2026.

Does Peec AI track Claude?

Peec AI's Starter, Pro and Advanced plans list 8 selectable models, and Claude is not among them. Its Enterprise list names Claude models, with up to 26 models in total. AthenaHQ Starter and Noma both cover Claude.

Do these tools tell you what to fix?

Yes, all three present tasks or recommendations. Peec AI has an Actions page with briefs and corrections, AthenaHQ lists on-page and off-page actions, and Noma gives recommendations to improve AI visibility. Test one real task in each before buying.

Does Noma have a free trial?

Noma has a 3-day free trial. A card is taken at signup and billing starts on day 3, with no charge if you cancel before then. Prices are in USD.

Can I switch tools without losing my data?

Usually you can export your history and recreate your prompts. Our guide to switching an AI search visibility platform covers what to export first and how to keep your trend lines.

See it with your own goal

Leave your work email and pick a time.